| #4 Lynch 37.0455 (3-21) | Match 1
11/02/2009
5:00 PM CT | | #5 Niobrara 36.2273 (3-20) | | |
| | #1 Stuart 42.8519 (20-10) | Match 3
11/02/2009
7:30 PM CT | | Lynch (3-1) | | #3 Verdigre 38.5500 (7-14) | Match 2
11/02/2009
6:15 PM CT | | #2 St. Mary's 42.2727 (17-7) |
| | Stuart (3-0) | Match 4
11/03/2009
7:00 PM CT | | St. Mary's (3-2) |
| |