| #4 Clarkson 42.1600 (14-12) | Match 1
11/02/2009
5:00 PM CT | | #5 Scribner-Snyder 41.5000 (16-16) | | |
| | #1 Howells 43.8214 (25-6) | Match 3
11/02/2009
8:00 PM CT | | Scribner-Snyder (3-1) | | #3 Humphrey St. Francis 42.4167 (15-13) | Match 2
11/02/2009
6:30 PM CT | | #2 Humphrey 43.5385 (19-8) |
| | Howells (3-1) | Match 4
11/03/2009
6:30 PM CT | | Humphrey St. Francis (3-1) |
| |