| #4 Alliance 40.7931 (17-14) | Match 1
11/05/2009
4:30 PM MT | | #5 Sidney 37.1379 (6-25) | | |
| | #1 Ogallala 44.2903 (27-6) | Match 3
11/05/2009
7:30 PM MT | | Alliance (3-0) | | #3 Gering 41.2308 (15-12) | Match 2
11/05/2009
6:00 PM MT | | #2 Scottsbluff 41.8387 (20-16) |
| | Ogallala (3-0) | Match 4
11/06/2009
7:00 PM MT | | Scottsbluff (3-1) |
| |