#4 Garden County 38.2500 (7-17) | Game 1 02/12/2024 6:00 PM MT | #5 Creek Valley 37.3750 (5-13) | |
| #1 Paxton 42.5000 (17-9) | Game 2 02/13/2024 5:30 PM MT | Garden County (40-19) | #3 Arthur County 39.7778 (10-11) | Game 3 02/13/2024 7:00 PM MT | #2 Wallace 40.2381 (8-15) |
| Paxton (46-26) | Game 4 02/15/2024 6:00 PM MT | Arthur County (40-36) |
| |