| Play/School | Judge 1 | Judge 2 | Judge 3 | Grand Total | PLACE | Reciprocal |
| Rank | Points | Rank | Points | Rank | Points | Rank | Points |
St. Mary's
"Dirt" | 1 |
59 | 2 |
58 | 1 |
60 | 4 |
177 |
1 |
2.5 |
Osmond
"Kiss of Death" | 3 |
58 | 1 |
59 | 2 |
56 | 6 |
173 |
2 |
1.83333 |
Chambers
"Fly Away" | 2 |
59 | 3 |
57 | 4 |
52 | 9 |
168 |
3 |
1.08333 |
Stuart
"Rap ID Recall" | 4 |
56 | 4 |
56 | 6 |
48 | 14 |
160 |
4 |
0.66667 |
Allen
"The One-Act Play That Goes Wrong" | 7 |
54 | 6 |
54 | 3 |
54 | 16 |
162 |
5 |
0.64286 |
Niobrara
""Penny for Your Thoughts"" | 6 |
54 | 5 |
55 | 5 |
52 | 16 |
161 |
6 |
0.56667 |
Verdigre
"That's Not How I Remember It" | 5 |
55 | 8 |
52 | 7 |
47 | 20 |
154 |
7 |
0.46786 |
Keya Paha County
"Hurricane Grandma" | 8 |
52 | 7 |
53 | 8 |
42 | 23 |
147 |
8 |
0.39286 |
| Outstanding Technical Crew | |
| Outstanding Male Performer | |
| Outstanding Female Performer | |