| #4 Central City 38.7586 (7-23) | Match 1
11/02/2009
5:00 PM CT | | #5 Boone Central 38.7273 (9-15) | | |
| | #1 Columbus Scotus 46.2609 (21-5) | Match 3
11/02/2009
8:00 PM CT | | Boone Central (3-0) | | #3 Columbus Lakeview 43.6429 (22-7) | Match 2
11/02/2009
6:30 PM CT | | #2 St. Paul 43.7241 (24-7) |
| | Columbus Scotus (3-0) | Match 4
11/03/2009
7:00 PM CT | | St. Paul (3-0) |
| |